For public employers and private organizations alike, employee complaints are an unavoidable part of operations. Allegations involving harassment, discrimination, retaliation, or workplace misconduct require not only prompt attention, but a thoughtful and defensible response. While many organizations default to handling investigations internally, that approach can introduce risk, particularly in intense matters.
Engaging an outside legal investigator, often an employment attorney, offers significant advantages that go beyond simply outsourcing the work, strengthening the integrity of the investigation, protecting the organization, and positioning employers to respond effectively and lawfully.
Key Advantages and Cost Risks of Internal Investigations
Engaging an outside legal investigator, often an employment attorney, offers significant advantages that go beyond simply outsourcing the work. It strengthens the integrity of the investigation, protects the organization, and positions employers to respond effectively and lawfully.
Investigations conducted without legal guidance can be costly. In 2025, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) secured a record $660 million for discrimination victims, with $528 million recovered pre-litigation, which was mostly tied to flawed workplace investigations that could have been mitigated by early legal involvement.
1. Early Legal Insight into Complex Employment Law Issues
Identifying Hidden Legal Nuances
Employment attorneys are specially trained to identify legal issues that are not obvious to those not trained in the field. Since employment issues possess specific complexities and nuances, engaging an experienced attorney ensures a thorough and fair investigation.
Proactive Risk Management
An experienced employment lawyer brings crucial skills to spot issues that may offer opportunity for correction by the employer. Workplace complaints rarely exist in a vacuum; they often implicate overlapping legal standards, internal policies, and regulatory obligations. A legal investigator can quickly identify potential exposure, assess risk, and tailor the investigation accordingly.
This early insight helps employers avoid common pitfalls, such as overlooking retaliation risks or mishandling supervisor-related allegations. Instead of reacting after problems arise, employers can proactively manage risk from the outset.
HR Laws Every Professional Should Know
2. Protection Through Attorney-Client Privilege
One of the most significant advantages of hiring an employment lawyer as a legal investigator is the potential application of attorney-client privilege and work-product protections. These protections can allow for candid internal discussions about risk, liability, and strategy.
While privilege is not automatic and must be carefully preserved, structuring the investigation through counsel increases the likelihood that sensitive communications and findings remain protected. This is especially important when litigation is anticipated or ongoing, as seen in Pennsylvania cases like Javitz v. Luzerne County, where concrete steps were followed so that privilege claims survived.
3. Independence and Credibility in Workplace Investigations
Perception matters in workplace investigations. Internal investigators, no matter how well-intentioned, may be viewed as biased, particularly when investigating colleagues, supervisors, or leadership.
An outside legal investigator provides a level of independence that enhances credibility. Employees, governing bodies, and even courts are more likely to trust findings from a neutral third party. This independence signals that the employer is committed to uncovering the truth and not protecting a predetermined outcome.
4. A Defensible and Consistent Legal Process
Employment attorneys who conduct investigations rely on established methodologies that ensure consistency and thoroughness. From defining scope and planning interviews to evaluating witness credibility and documenting findings, a legal investigator follows a structured approach that can withstand scrutiny.
If the investigation is later challenged, whether in litigation, arbitration, or a public forum, the employer can point to a well-documented, professional process as evidence of fairness and diligence.
5. Actionable, Legally Sound Outcomes for Your Business
An investigation does not end with findings; it requires informed action. A legal investigator can connect the results of the investigation to appropriate remedial measures, disciplinary decisions, and policy improvements.
Because an employment lawyer understands the legal implications of each potential response, their recommendations help proactive business law teams avoid compounding risk. They also assist in aligning outcomes with compliance obligations and long-term organizational goals.
When to Engage an Outside Legal Investigator
Not every complaint requires outside counsel. Employers should strongly consider hiring an employment attorney as a legal investigator when:
- The complaint involves harassment, discrimination, or retaliation
- A supervisor or senior official is implicated
- The allegations are complex or involve multiple parties
- There is a risk of litigation or public scrutiny
- Internal neutrality may reasonably be questioned
In these situations, the benefits of independence, legal analysis, and procedural accuracy far outweigh the cost of external engagement.
Strengthening Your Organization’s Response
Hiring an outside legal investigator is not just about managing a single complaint, but also about protecting the organization. A well-conducted investigation demonstrates accountability, reduces legal exposure, and reinforces trust within the workplace.
For public employers, where transparency and credibility are paramount, partnering with an experienced employment lawyer can make the difference between a defensible process and a costly misstep.
Secure an Independent Investigation for Your Organization
MBM Law delivers comprehensive employment law services for businesses and public entities across Pennsylvania. We help organizations of all sizes navigate complex local, state, and federal compliance requirements, avoid legal risks, and build stronger, more resilient workplaces. Our Legal Investigation Team offers a strategic and practical approach for your organization.
Schedule a Consultation with Our Legal Team
As Senior Counsel at MBM Law, Peter J. Halesey specializes in labor and employment law, and also focuses on municipal and education law. He represents municipalities and school districts in grievance arbitrations, collective bargaining negotiations, and employment-related litigation.